University of Tennessee athletic director Danny White has been beating the drum for more than a year about bringing collective bargaining to college sports. White says it’s the only sustainable path forward for college athletics in an age when schools are paying millions of dollars to players annually.
White put his words into practice last week as the UT men’s basketball team released a proposed collective bargaining term sheet. The document resulted from negotiations with the UT athletic administration and includes a salary cap and spending floor, eligibility and transfer rules and cap circumvention enforcement.
The Vols elected Tyler Lundblade, Campbell Duncan and DeWayne Brown II to be player representatives and work with Athletes.Org, a group representing college athletes, to negotiate with the UT athletic department to complete the process.
The groups held several rounds of discussions in August and September. The deal was reached Oct. 1.
Although it has no practical implications, the mock exercise was meant to show what an agreement between athletes and a university can look like if ever implemented and adopted across college sports, according to Athletes.org.
“We take a lot of pride in being extremely athlete-centric, and listening to our players’ interests through Athletes.org has shown that sharing perspectives through meaningful dialogue isn’t something to be afraid of,” White says. “Collective bargaining is a proven model that works across all of professional sports and, through Athletes.org, athletes can help create a healthy, durable solution for the future of college athletics.”
The current maximum a school can share with athletes is $21.5 million annually. But most major programs exceed that total through third-party NIL deals, many of which are brokered by third parties associated with schools.
In the hypothetical term sheet created by UT and Athletes.org, NIL would no longer be used as a recruiting inducement and be replaced by a salary structure that would more resemble what currently exists in professional leagues.
White says it is “intellectually dishonest” to claim that players are earning most of their money from NIL.
“We’re paying them to play sports,” White says. “We’re doing that because we lost several court cases that said we’re violating antitrust law by not doing so. We need to accept our legal reality. By not accepting it, we’ve created this system that’s the most inefficient way I can think of for building rosters and organizing this thing.”
Unprecedented path
College athletes can’t bargain as a union in the current landscape because they are not considered employees of their schools. Previous unionization efforts by college athletes have failed.
Skeptics of collective bargaining in college sports say unionization is not possible for a few reasons, including laws in some states that block employees of public institutions from collective bargaining. Proponents of the idea propose creating a private company to act as the centralized employer of college athletes to get around the state laws.
UT’s hypothetical term sheet also includes language on health coverage, postseason revenue pools, player performance pools and a retention pool for athletes who stay and play at the same university for at least two years.
The term sheet states that the CBA would cover an initial four-year window with renewal negotiations permitted up to two years before expiration.
“Some people say we’re kids, that we’re immature or that we don’t understand. But we’re the ones living this experience, and our opinions matter,” Brown says. “We know what we want and how we want to move forward. Working through the collective bargaining process has been great, and I hope it’s just a steppingstone for more college athletes to replicate our process with their own schools.”
White has been advocating for collective bargaining rather than seeking government intervention, which the NCAA and member conferences have been trying to obtain through the Protect College Sports Act. The bill garnered bipartisan support in the Senate in September, but is facing obstacles in the House, even more so after Democrats swept the midterms.
Lundblade, a redshirt senior transfer from Belmont, appreciated the chance to take part in the mock CBA negotiations and possibly become a trendsetter.
“I think that’s a very big step for college athletics and there are a lot of legal hurdles, but I don’t see a reason why a CBA couldn’t work in college sports,” Lundblade says. “Especially given that college sports are now pretty much professional sports, and it’s worked in every sports league.
“It was really cool to be a part of and work on it pretty much every week the entire summer and fall and joining Zooms on Friday night,” Lundblade continues. “All that kind of stuff was a grind but it was fun and very cool to see what it is now.”
Information/full text of the CBA