Hamilton Herald Masthead

Editorial


Front Page - Friday, November 20, 2026

Stare decisis principle lights the way for court decisions




Courts are bound by the laws legislatures pass and are, of course, obligated to apply them. They must also follow another source of law: binding precedent from higher courts. This principle is called stare decisis, a Latin phrase meaning “to stand by things decided.”

Stare decisis is one of the foundations on which the stability, predictability, consistency and integrity of our federal courts rest. As such, it is a crucial component of the rule of law.

Stare decisis

At its simplest, stare decisis means that when a court is presented with a case that involves similar legal questions and circumstances as a case previously decided by that court or a higher court, the new court should generally follow the legal principles established in that earlier decision.

Rather than treating every case as presenting entirely new legal questions, judges look to previous decisions for guidance and, in most circumstances, must follow them.

Without the benefit of stare decisis, a litigant who went to court to resolve a legal dispute could not anticipate which legal principles would govern the case; it would depend on which judge happened to hear the case.

A principle accepted by one judge might be rejected by another. A decision rendered yesterday might have no bearing on a nearly identical case decided tomorrow.

The law would become unpredictable, inconsistent and subject to the personal preference of individual judges. Litigants with identical legal arguments could suffer different outcomes because of the dispositions of their individual judges.

Adhering to precedent helps guard against that possibility.

The hierarchical structure of the judiciary

Precedent works because of the hierarchical structure of the federal judiciary. At the bottom are the federal district courts, where cases are initially tried and evidence is developed.

Above them are the federal courts of appeals, which each hear appeals from a specific geographic area (referred to as a “circuit”) or appeals of a certain type of case.

At the top is the United States Supreme Court. A decision by the Supreme Court establishes a rule of law that all lower federal courts must follow – district courts and courts of appeals alike.

A decision by a court of appeals establishes a rule of law that all district courts within its circuit must follow. Lower courts are obligated to follow prior decisions of higher courts even if judges on the lower courts disagree with the reasoning or outcome of the decision.

A judge may honestly and conscientiously believe that an earlier decision was incorrectly decided, poorly reasoned, or inconsistent with the judge’s own understanding of the law. Nevertheless, if that decision constitutes binding precedent, the judge generally must follow it.

Far from compromising judicial independence, adherence to these principles reflects the responsibility and discipline the judiciary demands of itself.

Precedent can be changed

Stare decisis also means that, as a general rule, the Supreme Court will follow its own prior decisions, and a court of appeals will follow its own prior decisions.

But while a lower court is not free to ignore precedent from a higher court, higher courts are free to change their own earlier decisions. So the Supreme Court can reverse a principle established in one of its earlier decisions, and the courts of appeals can reverse principles established in their earlier decisions.

Precedent is entitled to respect and careful consideration, but precedent is not intended to be set in stone forever. Courts sometimes come to realize that an earlier decision was erroneous and should be adjusted or even rejected.

The Supreme Court examines a number of factors when it reconsiders an earlier opinion. It considers whether the earlier decision was seriously flawed – not just whether it was wrongly decided. That is because only a serious flaw is enough to justify a departure from stare decisis.

If merely believing a precedent was wrongly decided were enough to overturn that precedent, the principle of stare decisis would begin to erode.

The Supreme Court also considers whether the earlier decision has proved unworkable, whether subsequent legal developments have undermined the earlier decision’s reasoning, and whether individuals and institutions have developed substantial reliance interests in light of the earlier decision.

A powerful example of changing precedent is the famous Supreme Court decision of Brown v. Board of Education in 1954. For over 50 years, binding precedent had held that separate-but-equal public facilities were constitutional based on the Supreme Court’s 1896 decision in Plessy v. Ferguson.

After considering the relevant factors, the Supreme Court in Brown overturned the Plessy decision.

The Brown example demonstrates that while adherence to precedent is important for stability and predictability in the law, it must be balanced against the obligation to interpret the Constitution faithfully.

Respect for prior judicial decisions is important, but it does not go so far as to require higher courts to perpetuate serious constitutional errors.

Conclusion

Precedent, or stare decisis, is an important component of the rule of law. It helps ensure that the law is not reinvented every time a new judge takes the bench or a different judge is assigned a case.

Without precedent, the federal judiciary would risk becoming a collection of individual judges applying individual notions of what the law is. This would result in distrust of the law and chaos in society.

With precedent, judges operate within an established framework of legal principles that promote consistency, predictability, fairness and institutional continuity.

The genius of stare decisis is that it reminds us that the law should not change simply because the person occupying the judicial chair has changed. At the same time, it ensures that our body of law is not so rigid that errors can never be righted.

The balance encompassed in the principle of stare decisis is an essential safeguard of the rule of law.

Curtis L. Collier

U.S. district judge

Chair, Eastern District of Tennessee Civics and Outreach Committee

Carrie Brown Stefaniak

Molly E. Pines

Melissa L. Skarjune

Law clerks to the Hon. Curtis L. Collier